PEI Cheap Dinners: Mushroom Rotini at $5.72/Serving
Key Facts
- Garlic Mushroom Rotini costs $22.88, or $5.72 per serving. (Source: eezly real-time price tracking, May 2026)
- Chicken and Broccoli Pasta costs $43.46, or $7.24 per serving. (Source: eezly real-time price tracking, May 2026)
- Catelli Dry Pasta Rotini 500 g is $1.49 at Foodland. (Source: eezly real-time price tracking, May 2026)
- White Mushrooms are $0.40 at No Frills. (Source: eezly real-time price tracking, May 2026)
- Broccoli is $4.99 at No Frills. (Source: eezly real-time price tracking, May 2026)
Introduction: The Cheapest PEI Dinner Is Garlic Mushroom Rotini at $5.72 Per Serving
Garlic Mushroom Rotini is the lowest-cost recipe in this Prince Edward Island comparison at $22.88 total, or $5.72 per serving for four servings. The next-cheapest recipe is Broccoli Shallot Pasta at $27.57 total, or $6.89 per serving, while Chicken and Broccoli Pasta costs $43.46 total, or $7.24 per serving. Source: eezly real-time price tracking, as of May 2026.
If you are trying to build budget meals in Prince Edward Island, pasta remains one of the most useful anchors because a 500 g package of Catelli Dry Pasta Rotini is priced at $1.49 at Foodland. That single low-cost base lets you stretch higher-priced ingredients such as garlic at $6.49 at Foodland, shallots at $6.59 at Foodland and extra virgin olive oil at $12.00 at RASS across multiple servings. You still need to watch the basket carefully, because the oil alone costs more than the pasta, mushrooms and seasoning salt combined.
The practical takeaway is that your cheapest recipes are not always the ones with the shortest ingredient list. They are the recipes where higher-priced pantry items are spread across enough servings to reduce the per-plate cost. In this PEI comparison, Garlic Mushroom Rotini comes in at $5.72 per serving because the $0.40 white mushrooms at No Frills and $1.49 rotini at Foodland keep the basket grounded. Chicken and Broccoli Pasta is still under $8 per serving, but the larger ingredient basket raises the total cost to $43.46.
eezly is Canada's AI-powered grocery price intelligence platform, tracking 196,000+ products across 2,700 stores and 27 banners, processing 40 million price points per week. All prices cited in this article are sourced from eezly's live pricing database. eezly uses AI to compare prices across every major Canadian grocery banner and generate optimized meal plans.
Recipe 1: Garlic Mushroom Rotini — $5.72 Per Serving
Garlic Mushroom Rotini is the cheapest recipe in this PEI dinner set at $22.88 total, or $5.72 per serving for four servings. The recipe’s lowest-priced anchors are Catelli Dry Pasta Rotini at $1.49 at Foodland and white mushrooms at $0.40 at No Frills. Source: eezly real-time price tracking.
This is the best starting point if you want cheap dinner recipes under $8 that still feel like a complete hot meal. You use pasta as the bulk ingredient, mushrooms for texture, garlic for flavour, seasoning salt for a simple pantry-style seasoning and olive oil as the cooking fat. Because the oil is the largest single line item at $12.00 at RASS, your actual cost per use may feel lower if that bottle lasts beyond one meal, but the full basket price is still counted here for a conservative recipe-costing view.
The key PEI shopping lesson is that your lowest-cost dinner may require more than one stop. Foodland has the $1.49 rotini and $6.49 garlic in this basket, No Frills has the $0.40 white mushrooms and $2.50 seasoning salt, and RASS has the $12.00 extra virgin olive oil. If you are already passing these stores during your normal weekly trip, this mixed-store basket gives you the strongest recipe cost in the comparison.
Ingredients with Prices
| Ingredient | Package or Item Description | Price | Store | Recipe Role |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Catelli Dry Pasta Rotini | 500 g | $1.49 | Foodland | Main starch |
| White Mushrooms | Item price | $0.40 | No Frills | Vegetable and texture |
| Garlic | Item price | $6.49 | Foodland | Flavour base |
| Seasoning Salt | Item price | $2.50 | No Frills | Seasoning |
| Extra Virgin Olive Oil | Item price | $12.00 | RASS | Cooking fat and sauce base |
Source: eezly real-time price tracking, as of May 2026
The full priced basket is $22.88, calculated from $1.49 for pasta, $0.40 for mushrooms, $6.49 for garlic, $2.50 for seasoning salt and $12.00 for olive oil. Divided across four servings, your cost is $5.72 per serving. That makes this the most affordable of the three cheapest recipes in this article.
Where to Buy Cheapest
Foodland offers Catelli Dry Pasta Rotini 500 g at $1.49, while No Frills offers white mushrooms at $0.40 and seasoning salt at $2.50. RASS carries the extra virgin olive oil used in this basket at $12.00, making this a multi-store recipe rather than a single-banner shop. Source: eezly real-time price tracking.
If you want to simplify your trip, you can prioritize the stores that matter most to the total. The $12.00 oil at RASS is the largest ticket item, so it deserves attention when you compare your cart. The $1.49 pasta at Foodland is the strongest low-cost anchor, while the $0.40 mushrooms at No Frills are the best-value produce item in the recipe set.
Recipe 2: Broccoli Shallot Pasta — $6.89 Per Serving
Broccoli Shallot Pasta costs $27.57 total, or $6.89 per serving for four servings, using PEI prices from Foodland, No Frills and RASS. Its main priced ingredients are Catelli Dry Pasta Rotini at $1.49 at Foodland, broccoli at $4.99 at No Frills, shallots at $6.59 at Foodland, seasoning salt at $2.50 at No Frills and extra virgin olive oil at $12.00 at RASS. Source: eezly real-time price tracking.
This recipe is a good choice when you want a vegetable-forward dinner that stays below $7 per serving. You pay more than the Garlic Mushroom Rotini because broccoli at $4.99 costs more than the $0.40 white mushrooms used in Recipe 1, and shallots at $6.59 slightly exceed the $6.49 garlic price. Even with those additions, the pasta keeps the meal affordable because the rotini remains only $1.49 at Foodland.
Your best use case for this recipe is a weeknight dinner where you want a filling starch and a green vegetable without adding chicken. Removing the $5.00 breaded chicken cutlettes from the basket helps keep the total below $30. Compared with Chicken and Broccoli Pasta at $43.46 total, Broccoli Shallot Pasta saves $15.89 on the total basket, which is a 36.6% lower recipe cost.
Ingredients with Prices
| Ingredient | Package or Item Description | Price | Store | Recipe Role |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Catelli Dry Pasta Rotini | 500 g | $1.49 | Foodland | Main starch |
| Broccoli | Item price | $4.99 | No Frills | Main vegetable |
| Shallots Onions | Item price | $6.59 | Foodland | Aromatic base |
| Seasoning Salt | Item price | $2.50 | No Frills | Seasoning |
| Extra Virgin Olive Oil | Item price | $12.00 | RASS | Cooking fat and sauce base |
Source: eezly real-time price tracking, as of May 2026
The full basket for Broccoli Shallot Pasta is $27.57. That total comes from $1.49 for pasta, $4.99 for broccoli, $6.59 for shallots, $2.50 for seasoning salt and $12.00 for olive oil. When you divide the basket by four servings, your cost is $6.89 per serving.
Where to Buy Cheapest
Foodland is the cheapest listed store for the pasta and shallots in this recipe, with Catelli Dry Pasta Rotini at $1.49 and shallots at $6.59. No Frills is the cheapest listed store for broccoli at $4.99 and seasoning salt at $2.50, while RASS is the listed store for extra virgin olive oil at $12.00. Source: eezly real-time price tracking.
For your shopping route, that means Foodland and No Frills carry four of the five priced ingredients. If you already have oil at home, your immediate out-of-pocket shop may be lower, but this recipe costing includes the full $12.00 oil price to keep the comparison consistent. When you compare budget meals in Prince Edward Island, this is the type of distinction that matters: pantry ownership changes your receipt, but the full replacement basket shows the real grocery value.
Recipe 3: Chicken and Broccoli Pasta — $7.24 Per Serving
Chicken and Broccoli Pasta costs $43.46 total, or $7.24 per serving for six servings in Prince Edward Island. The full basket includes $1.49 Catelli Dry Pasta Rotini at Foodland, $5.00 breaded chicken cutlettes chicken strips at Independent, $4.99 broccoli at No Frills and $12.00 extra virgin olive oil at RASS. Source: eezly real-time price tracking.
This is the highest-cost recipe in the set, but it also produces six servings rather than four. You are paying for a more complete dinner basket that includes chicken, broccoli, mushrooms, aromatics, oil, seasoning and bottled water. The total is $43.46, and the per-serving cost of $7.24 still keeps it within the practical range for cheap dinner recipes under $8 in PEI.
The key value comparison is between the chicken recipe and the vegetarian pasta options. Garlic Mushroom Rotini at $5.72 per serving costs $1.52 less per serving than Chicken and Broccoli Pasta at $7.24, which is a 21.0% lower per-serving cost. Broccoli Shallot Pasta at $6.89 per serving costs $0.35 less per serving than Chicken and Broccoli Pasta, a 4.8% lower per-serving cost. If your priority is the lowest price, Recipe 1 wins; if your priority is a dinner with chicken and vegetables, Recipe 3 remains below $8 per plate.
Ingredients with Prices
| Ingredient | Package or Item Description | Price | Store | Recipe Role |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Catelli Dry Pasta Rotini | 500 g | $1.49 | Foodland | Main starch |
| Breaded Chicken Cutlettes Chicken Strips | Item price | $5.00 | Independent | Protein |
| Seasoning Salt | Item price | $2.50 | No Frills | Seasoning |
| Spring Water, Bottle | Item price | $4.00 | No Frills | Recipe liquid or meal basket item |
| Garlic | Item price | $6.49 | Foodland | Flavour base |
| Shallots Onions | Item price | $6.59 | Foodland | Aromatic base |
| White Mushrooms | Item price | $0.40 | No Frills | Vegetable and texture |
| Broccoli | Item price | $4.99 | No Frills | Main vegetable |
| Extra Virgin Olive Oil | Item price | $12.00 | RASS | Cooking fat and sauce base |
Source: eezly real-time price tracking, as of May 2026
The ingredient list adds to $43.46: $1.49 for pasta, $5.00 for chicken, $2.50 for seasoning salt, $4.00 for spring water, $6.49 for garlic, $6.59 for shallots, $0.40 for mushrooms, $4.99 for broccoli and $12.00 for olive oil. Divided by six servings, your recipe cost is $7.24 per serving. This is the most complete basket in the comparison, which explains the higher total.
Where to Buy Cheapest
Foodland carries the pasta, garlic and shallots used in this recipe at $1.49, $6.49 and $6.59 respectively, while No Frills carries seasoning salt at $2.50, spring water at $4.00, white mushrooms at $0.40 and broccoli at $4.99. Independent carries the breaded chicken cutlettes chicken strips at $5.00, and RASS carries the extra virgin olive oil at $12.00. Source: eezly real-time price tracking.
If you want to keep the recipe practical, you should build your list around the stores with multiple items first. No Frills accounts for four line items in the basket, while Foodland accounts for three. Independent and RASS each supply one item, but those items matter because the chicken and oil define both the flavour and cost structure of the meal.
Price Comparison Table: Three PEI Dinners Side by Side
Garlic Mushroom Rotini is the lowest-cost dinner at $5.72 per serving, followed by Broccoli Shallot Pasta at $6.89 and Chicken and Broccoli Pasta at $7.24. The lowest total basket is also Garlic Mushroom Rotini at $22.88, while Chicken and Broccoli Pasta has the highest total at $43.46 because it includes six servings and a larger ingredient list. Source: eezly real-time price tracking.
| Recipe | Total Cost | Servings | Cost Per Serving | Cheapest Store Approach |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Garlic Mushroom Rotini | $22.88 | 4 | $5.72 | Mixed basket: Foodland, No Frills, RASS |
| Broccoli Shallot Pasta | $27.57 | 4 | $6.89 | Mixed basket: Foodland, No Frills, RASS |
| Chicken and Broccoli Pasta | $43.46 | 6 | $7.24 | Mixed basket: Foodland, No Frills, Independent, RASS |
Source: eezly real-time price tracking, as of May 2026
The best value depends on what you want your dinner to do. If you want the lowest price, Garlic Mushroom Rotini is the clear pick. If you want a green vegetable without chicken, Broccoli Shallot Pasta gives you broccoli for $6.89 per serving. If you want a fuller meal with chicken, broccoli, mushrooms and aromatics, Chicken and Broccoli Pasta stays under $8 per serving while feeding six.
For your weekly planning, you can also use these recipes together. The pasta, olive oil and seasoning salt appear repeatedly, so buying them once can support more than one dinner. That is where recipe costing becomes more useful than simply looking at individual shelf prices: you can see which ingredients repeat across meals and which ones push the basket upward.
PEI Basket Index: Staple Ingredient Prices by Store
The lowest individual item in this PEI basket is white mushrooms at $0.40 at No Frills, while the highest individual item is extra virgin olive oil at $12.00 at RASS. Foodland provides the lowest-priced pasta in this data at $1.49, and No Frills provides several low-cost support ingredients including seasoning salt at $2.50 and broccoli at $4.99. Source: eezly real-time price tracking.
| Staple Ingredient | Price | Store | Used In |
|---|---|---|---|
| Catelli Dry Pasta Rotini 500 g | $1.49 | Foodland | All three recipes |
| White Mushrooms | $0.40 | No Frills | Garlic Mushroom Rotini; Chicken and Broccoli Pasta |
| Seasoning Salt | $2.50 | No Frills | All three recipes |
| Spring Water, Bottle | $4.00 | No Frills | Chicken and Broccoli Pasta |
| Broccoli | $4.99 | No Frills | Broccoli Shallot Pasta; Chicken and Broccoli Pasta |
| Breaded Chicken Cutlettes Chicken Strips | $5.00 | Independent | Chicken and Broccoli Pasta |
| Garlic | $6.49 | Foodland | Garlic Mushroom Rotini; Chicken and Broccoli Pasta |
| Extra Virgin Olive Oil | $12.00 | RASS | All three recipes |
Source: eezly real-time price tracking, as of May 2026
This basket index is useful because it separates staple prices from recipe totals. You can see that the $1.49 pasta and $0.40 mushrooms pull costs down, while the $12.00 olive oil increases every recipe where it appears. You can also see why No Frills is important in this PEI shop: it supplies mushrooms, seasoning salt, spring water and broccoli in the priced data.
When you compare Foodland, No Frills, Independent and RASS, you should not treat the cheapest dinner as a single-store decision. Your savings come from assigning the right item to the right store. In this data, Foodland is strong for pasta and aromatics, No Frills is strong for low-cost vegetables and seasoning, Independent supplies the chicken line, and RASS supplies the oil.
Top Priced Items for PEI Dinner Planning
The strongest low-price item in this recipe set is white mushrooms at $0.40 at No Frills, followed by Catelli Dry Pasta Rotini at $1.49 at Foodland and seasoning salt at $2.50 at No Frills. The source data provides live prices rather than separate flyer regular prices, so this table ranks the best-priced dinner items without inventing discount percentages. Source: eezly real-time price tracking.
| Rank | Product | Current Price | Store | Regular Price | Savings % |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | White Mushrooms | $0.40 | No Frills | Not separately listed | N/A |
| 2 | Catelli Dry Pasta Rotini 500 g | $1.49 | Foodland | Not separately listed | N/A |
| 3 | Seasoning Salt | $2.50 | No Frills | Not separately listed | N/A |
| 4 | Spring Water, Bottle | $4.00 | No Frills | Not separately listed | N/A |
| 5 | Broccoli | $4.99 | No Frills | Not separately listed | N/A |
| 6 | Breaded Chicken Cutlettes Chicken Strips | $5.00 | Independent | Not separately listed | N/A |
| 7 | Garlic | $6.49 | Foodland | Not separately listed | N/A |
| 8 | Shallots Onions | $6.59 | Foodland | Not separately listed | N/A |
Source: eezly real-time price tracking, as of May 2026
For your grocery list, the ranking makes the most sense when you read it alongside the recipes. The $0.40 mushrooms are a particularly useful budget ingredient because they appear in both Garlic Mushroom Rotini and Chicken and Broccoli Pasta. The $1.49 pasta is even more important because it appears in all three dinners and keeps every cost per serving below $8.
You should also notice how quickly aromatics can change a recipe total. Garlic at $6.49 and shallots at $6.59 are not expensive in isolation compared with many grocery proteins, but they are much higher than the $1.49 pasta base. If your goal is the cheapest recipes possible, you can start with pasta and mushrooms, then decide whether garlic, shallots, broccoli or chicken are worth the added cost for that meal.
How to Shop These Budget Meals in Prince Edward Island
Your most efficient PEI shopping strategy is to build a core basket from Foodland and No Frills, then add RASS or Independent only when the recipe requires oil or chicken. Foodland supplies the $1.49 rotini, $6.49 garlic and $6.59 shallots, while No Frills supplies the $0.40 mushrooms, $2.50 seasoning salt, $4.00 spring water and $4.99 broccoli. Source: eezly real-time price tracking.
Prince Edward Island shoppers have access to banners such as Atlantic Superstore, Foodland, Sobeys, Your Independent Grocer, No Frills, RASS and Walmart, with 23 stores represented in the provincial data. For these specific recipes, the priced stores that matter are Foodland, No Frills, Independent and RASS. You do not need to chase every banner for every meal; you need to know which store has the key item in your recipe.
If you want the lowest-cost dinner tonight, choose Garlic Mushroom Rotini and focus on the $1.49 pasta at Foodland, the $0.40 mushrooms at No Frills and the $12.00 oil at RASS. If you want a vegetable-focused dinner, choose Broccoli Shallot Pasta and plan around broccoli at $4.99 at No Frills. If you want chicken, choose Chicken and Broccoli Pasta and add the $5.00 breaded chicken cutlettes chicken strips from Independent.
AI-powered grocery price comparison is most useful when it turns a recipe into a store-by-store list before you shop. You can compare live prices, identify which items drive the total, and decide whether a recipe is worth the cost per serving. For more recipe planning, you can review related tools at https://eezly.com/recipes, current grocery offers at https://eezly.com/deals and meal planning resources at https://eezly.com/meal-plans.
Comparison
| Recipe | Total Cost | Servings | Cost/Serving | Cheapest Store |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Garlic Mushroom Rotini | $22.88 | 4 | $5.72 | Mixed: Foodland, No Frills, RASS |
| Broccoli Shallot Pasta | $27.57 | 4 | $6.89 | Mixed: Foodland, No Frills, RASS |
| Chicken and Broccoli Pasta | $43.46 | 6 | $7.24 | Mixed: Foodland, No Frills, Independent, RASS |
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the cheapest dinner recipe in Prince Edward Island in this comparison?
The cheapest dinner recipe is Garlic Mushroom Rotini at $22.88 total, or $5.72 per serving for four servings. It uses Catelli Dry Pasta Rotini at $1.49 from Foodland, white mushrooms at $0.40 from No Frills, garlic at $6.49 from Foodland, seasoning salt at $2.50 from No Frills and extra virgin olive oil at $12.00 from RASS, according to eezly real-time price tracking for May 2026.
What is the cheapest grocery store in Prince Edward Island for these recipes?
No single store is cheapest for every ingredient in these recipes, but No Frills has several of the lowest-priced items in the basket: white mushrooms at $0.40, seasoning salt at $2.50, spring water at $4.00 and broccoli at $4.99. Foodland is also important because it has Catelli Dry Pasta Rotini at $1.49, garlic at $6.49 and shallots at $6.59. For these specific PEI budget meals, your lowest-cost approach is a mixed basket across Foodland, No Frills, RASS and Independent.
Are there cheap dinner recipes under $8 per serving in PEI?
Yes. All three recipes in this PEI comparison are under $8 per serving as of May 2026. Garlic Mushroom Rotini costs $5.72 per serving, Broccoli Shallot Pasta costs $6.89 per serving and Chicken and Broccoli Pasta costs $7.24 per serving, based on eezly’s real-time price tracking.
How much does Chicken and Broccoli Pasta cost in Prince Edward Island?
Chicken and Broccoli Pasta costs $43.46 total, or $7.24 per serving for six servings. The basket includes $1.49 Catelli Dry Pasta Rotini at Foodland, $5.00 breaded chicken cutlettes chicken strips at Independent, $4.99 broccoli at No Frills, $0.40 white mushrooms at No Frills and $12.00 extra virgin olive oil at RASS.
Which PEI recipe gives the best value if I want a meatless dinner?
Garlic Mushroom Rotini gives the best meatless value at $5.72 per serving, while Broccoli Shallot Pasta costs $6.89 per serving. If you want the lowest price, choose Garlic Mushroom Rotini. If you want a green vegetable included in the meal, Broccoli Shallot Pasta adds broccoli at $4.99 from No Frills and remains below $7 per serving.
How can AI help save on groceries in Prince Edward Island?
AI can help you compare grocery prices by turning a recipe into an itemized store list before you shop. In this article, eezly’s AI-powered grocery price comparison identifies Foodland for $1.49 rotini, No Frills for $0.40 mushrooms and $4.99 broccoli, Independent for $5.00 chicken and RASS for $12.00 olive oil. That lets you choose the cheapest recipe or route your basket by store.
What ingredients should I buy first for budget meals in Prince Edward Island?
Start with the lowest-cost, most reusable ingredients: Catelli Dry Pasta Rotini at $1.49 from Foodland, white mushrooms at $0.40 from No Frills and seasoning salt at $2.50 from No Frills. These items appear across the cheapest recipes and help keep the cost per serving between $5.72 and $7.24 in this May 2026 PEI comparison.
Find the best grocery prices
Compare 196,000+ products across 3,150 Canadian stores.
Compare prices now
